Start free
Transport · car finance

Cash, finance, a balloon or a lease — which costs least?

A balloon makes the instalment smaller, not the car cheaper. Pick the year you would sell, and see what the same car really costs you four ways — the value it loses, interest and fees, lease payments and the interest your cash could have earned.

How we calculate it

  • Everything is worked out to the year you sell — the headline, the charts and the table all stop there.
  • Cost to Own = everything paid, less what selling leaves you, plus lost interest. What selling leaves you is the car’s value less any loan still owing.
  • On day 0 cash pays the full price; bank finance and a balloon deal pay the deposit and the R1 207.50 initiation fee, then the instalment and R69 a month service fee.
  • A balloon is debt, not a cost. Sell before the end and it is settled from the sale like the rest of the loan; keep the car to the end and you pay it in one lump.
  • A lease has no equity — you never own the car, so its cost is simply its payments, plus the interest that money could have earned.
  • Every rand you pay out could have earned interest instead (on by default, at 7%; switch it off with the tick box) — cash gives up the most, so leaving it out flatters cash.
  • Rand as spent; fuel is the same whichever way you pay, and tax on interest earned is left out.

We calculate; we never recommend a bank, a dealer or a lease company. A balloon lowers the instalment, but you pay interest on the balloon for the whole term and still owe it at the end.

Where the typical figures come from

  • Interest rate — Low 10.75%, Moderate 12.75%, High 15.25%: prime is 10.75% since the Reserve Bank raised the repo rate to 7.25% in September 2026; Low is prime (a good-credit deal), Moderate is prime + 2 (ClearScore’s typical vehicle-finance rate), High is about what TopAuto reports for average credit. Briefly, SARB repo 7.25%; ClearScore; TopAuto.
  • Balloon — Low 20%, Moderate 30%, High 35% (the slider runs 0–35%): most banks cap a balloon at 35–40% of the price; cars.co.za’s worked example uses 35%; WesBank reported an average balloon of 37% on the 35% of new deals that had one (August 2025). cars.co.za, June 2026; FAnews / Standard Bank.
  • Term — 72 months: WesBank’s average new-car contract runs past 73 months; 84 months is offered. NADA.
  • Interest your cash could earn — Low 7%, Moderate 8.75%, High 9.75%: GoTyme Bank’s 12-month (8.75%) and 36-month (9.75%) fixed deposits, July 2026; Low is our estimate for a money-market fund. GoTyme Bank.
  • Fees: the National Credit Act caps the initiation fee on a vehicle loan at R1 207.50 and the service fee at R69 a month (VAT included) — check your quote. TimesLIVE.
  • Car prices: VW Polo Vivo 1.4 Life R271 900, Toyota Corolla Cross 1.8 XS R458 400, Toyota Hilux 2.8 GD-6 SRX double cab auto R658 500 (cars.co.za / TopAuto, 2026); BMW X3 20 R1 047 760. cars.co.za, BMW X3.
  • Resale value: a new car typically loses 15–20% in its first year; Toyotas and bakkies hold value better. TimesLIVE / getWorth, 2024.
  • Our estimates, not sourced: each preset’s lease payment (about 1.8% of the price a month, scaled from Toyota Kinto’s Corolla Cross subscription), each car’s yearly loss in value, and the Low savings rate. Get a real lease quote — some include insurance and maintenance, some do not.

Services, maintenance, insurance and tyres are excluded because they apply to every option. Bank leases usually exclude insurance; if your lease or subscription bundles maintenance or insurance, it is better than shown by roughly what those would cost you.

Interactive tools and calculators

Work out the numbers behind this page on your own figures. Free, no sign-up.

Compare what you pay

Personal loan costs

What a personal loan really costs per lender: rate, fees and total repaid.

Compare loans →
Transport

Electric or hybrid car

The extra price against the fuel and servicing it saves: the year it pays for itself.

Compare my car →
Household money

Debt payoff

Snowball versus avalanche on your actual debts: which to clear first, and when you are free.

Plan my payoff →
Household money

Budget

See where every Rand goes and what is left at month-end.

Open Budget →