The truth about Black Friday specials: a was-price is only real if someone paid it
Four shops list the same 200g jar of Nescafe Gold Espresso at a "was" price of about R209, yet this week they sold it for R138 to R149.99 - so a "3 for 2" saves R70 off a price nobody was paying.

In 30 seconds
- The same 200g Nescafe Gold Espresso jar sold for R138 to R149.99 in four shops - while three of them showed a was-price of R209 or R209.99.
- "3 for 2" works out to R139.99 a jar - R1.99 more than one jar elsewhere at R138, and you have to buy three.
- One office chair went from R829 to R1 799 in three days, and its was-price from R1 299 to R2 499 - the "discount" got bigger as the price went up.
Every Black Friday badge is worked out from a was-price. The badge is only honest if that was-price is what the item normally sells for. Black Friday is on 27 November, so we went back through the prices we recorded between 18 and 22 November to see how often the was-price matches what shops actually charge.
The coffee jar: everyone's "was" price, nobody's real price
Here is the same product - Nescafe Gold Espresso, 200g - as each shop displayed it this week:
- Amazon.co.za: R138, "was R185.71" (seen 19 to 22 November).
- Checkers: R139.99 on a "3 for 2", "was R209.99" (seen 20 to 21 November).
- Takealot: R149, "was R209" (seen 18 November).
- Pick n Pay: R149.99, "was R209.99" (seen 18 to 22 November, unchanged).
Three shops show a was-price of about R209, and not one of them was selling it at R209 in the five days we watched. Pick n Pay charged R149.99 every single day.
The "3 for 2" is the clever part. Three jars cost R419.98, which is R139.99 each - a "33% saving" off R209.99. But one jar at R138 elsewhere is already cheaper, and measured against the R149.99 most shops actually charged, the real saving is about R10 a jar - on the condition that you buy three.
Our own records only go back to 18 November, so we pulled the 12-month price history pricecheck.co.za keeps for this jar (the lowest price across the shops it tracks, checked 22 November). In twelve months it never went above R149 - nowhere near R209. It was R149 last November, R129 over December and January, R143 in February and March, and R126 from April right through October.
So the R138 being promoted this week is not even a low. It is R12 more than this jar cost for most of 2026.
A long history can cut the other way too, which is why it is worth checking rather than assuming. A 100-pack of Finish All in One dishwasher tablets is R289 at Takealot this week, flagged about 32% off. Pricecheck's history shows it really did cost R429 in August and October, so that discount is real against recent months - but it was R229 at the end of last November, R60 less than this year's "deal".
When the price goes up, the "discount" can too
A was-price can move as easily as a price. Two listings we tracked at Makro this week:
- An office chair: R829 "was R1 299" on 18 November, R849 on 19 and 20 November, then R1 799 "was R2 499" from 21 November. The price more than doubled, and the badge still says you are saving R700.
- A towel rack: R379 "was R699", then R899 "was R1 399" for two days, then back to R379 "was R699".
If you saw that chair only on 21 November, R1 799 would look like 28% off. Seen across the week, it is R970 more than three days earlier.
Smaller items do it too. A 180g bag of KitKat Mini bars at Checkers was R59.99 with no special on the morning of 20 November, then R35.99 "was R59.99", then R40.19 "was R66.99" by that evening. The was-price rose R7 in a day.
Same was-price, different real price
Shops often copy the same was-price, so it tells you nothing about who is cheapest. Prices listed on 20 to 22 November:
- Domestos Power Foam 450ml: R35 at Amazon.co.za, R39.50 on a "2 for R79" at Checkers - both "was R59.99".
- Dettol Skin Detox bar soap 175g: R12.50 on "4 for R50" at Checkers, R15 on "2 for R30" at Pick n Pay - both "was R21.99".
- A DStv HD decoder: R199 at Incredible, R299 at HiFi Corp - both "was R899". That is R100 apart with the same 67% to 78% badges.
- An Epson EcoTank L3350 printer: R2 699 "was R3 999" in two shops - identical price, identical badge.
How to work out the true saving
- Use the lowest price you can find today, in any shop, as the yardstick - not the was-price. On sadeals.co.za, search the product name and sort by price.
- Check whether the price moved this month. A deal that has quietly gone up before Black Friday is not a deal.
- Work out multi-buys per item. "3 for 2" is only a saving if the per-item price beats a single item elsewhere, and if you will use all three.
- Count rands, not percent. Our four checks for fake discounts go through this step by step.
Was-prices above are as each shop displayed them. We record what shops show; we do not know how each shop sets its was-price, and a short price history cannot prove an item never sold at that price.
How MaxWealth helps
A "saving" bought on a card or store account keeps costing after the special ends. Debt payoff shows how long a balance takes to clear at your own repayment and interest rate, so you can weigh the discount against the interest before you choose credit.
Sources
- Checkers - Nescafe Gold Instant Espresso 200g, as displayed 20-21 November 2026.
- Pick n Pay - Nescafe Gold Espresso 200g, as displayed 18-22 November 2026.
- Takealot - Nescafe Gold Espresso 200g, as displayed 18 November 2026.
- Amazon.co.za - Nescafe Gold Espresso 200g, as displayed 19-22 November 2026.
- pricecheck.co.za - Nescafe Gold Espresso 200g price history (12-month history checked 22 November 2026).
- pricecheck.co.za - Finish All in One 100 tablets price history (12-month history checked 22 November 2026).
- Makro - Fine Living Apex office chair, as displayed 18-22 November 2026.
- Checkers - KitKat Mini chocolate bars 180g, as displayed 20-21 November 2026.
- All other prices: price records on sadeals.co.za, 18-22 November 2026, using each shop's displayed price and was-price.
Education, not financial advice. This post explains how the rules and the arithmetic work. It does not recommend any financial product, and your own situation may differ - speak to a registered financial adviser or tax practitioner before you act. Figures were checked against the linked sources on the date above.