Start free
← All posts Blog ·

How to spot a fake discount: four checks before the percentage decides for you

Of almost 12 000 specials we looked at this week, 2 120 claim 50% off or more - and a R255 camping lantern "was R1 560" while similar lanterns sell for R289 to R459.

A search for camping lanterns on sadeals.co.za showing discount badges from 23% to 84% on lanterns priced R289 to R895
Photo: Screenshot of sadeals.co.za (free licence)

In 30 seconds

  • 2 120 of 11 669 specials with a was-price claim 50% off or more - the average claim is 30%, so a huge number is common, not rare.
  • A R255 lantern "was R1 560" (84% off), but similar lanterns sell for R289 to R459 - the real saving is about R30 to R200, not R1 305.
  • The same camera kit was R12 545 in one store and R12 999 in another - a R454 gap that no percentage badge will show you.

A discount percentage is worked out from a was-price the seller chose. Sometimes that price was real for months; sometimes it existed for a week, or never. Black Friday is on 27 November, so here are four quick checks to run before a badge talks you into anything.

Check 1: what do similar items actually sell for?

Search for the item, not the deal. On sadeals.co.za, a search for "lantern" on 20 November showed:

  • Camping lanterns at R289, R369, R398 and R459, with was-prices of R599 to R910.
  • One lantern at R255, "was R1 560" - 84% off.

If comparable lanterns sell for R289 to R459, then R1 560 is decoration. The R255 lantern may still be the cheapest - which is a fine reason to buy it - but you are saving tens of rands, not R1 305.

Check 2: is it cheaper somewhere else today?

The same product can carry a different price, and a different "discount", in two shops at once. Among items listed by more than one store this week:

  • A camera creator kit: R12 545 in one store, R12 999 in another - R454 apart.
  • A 4K media player: R1 299 versus R1 399.

Most matching items were within 10% of each other, but you only know which side you are on if you look. Search by the model name and compare the price, not the badge.

Check 3: count the rands, not the percent

Of 11 669 specials with a was-price this week, 2 120 (18%) claim 50% or more, and 203 claim 70% or more. Another 3 255 (28%) are under 20% off. A big number is so common that it tells you little on its own.

  • Ask what you pay, and whether that is inside your ceiling for the item. Our Black Friday plan shows how to set one.
  • "Save R1 305" on something you were not going to buy is spending R255, not saving R1 305.

Check 4: read the deal type

  • Multi-buys ("2 for R30", "3 for 2") are only cheaper per item if you will use all of them before they expire or go out of style.
  • Bundles and kits raise the was-price by adding extras you may not need - compare the price of the main item alone.
  • The end date matters. A special ending in two days is pressure; check whether the same item was on special last month before you rush.

sadeals.co.za shows the was-price each store displays; it does not verify that the item ever sold at that price. Treat every was-price as the store's claim.

How MaxWealth helps

A "deal" bought on a card or store account keeps costing after the special ends. Debt payoff shows how long a balance takes to clear at your own repayment and interest rate, so you can compare the discount with the interest before you choose credit.

Sources

  • sadeals.co.za lantern search - prices, was-prices and discounts as displayed on 20 November 2026.
  • Discount counts: our own count of 11 669 new-condition specials with a was-price listed on sadeals.co.za on 20 November 2026, using each store's displayed was-price.
  • Store comparison: the 12 products listed by more than one store on sadeals.co.za on 20 November 2026.

Education, not financial advice. This post explains how the rules and the arithmetic work. It does not recommend any financial product, and your own situation may differ - speak to a registered financial adviser or tax practitioner before you act. Figures were checked against the linked sources on the date above.

← Back to all posts

Interactive tools and calculators

Every MaxWealth tool, on your own figures. Free, no sign-up.

Household money

Budget

See where every Rand goes and what is left at month-end.

Open Budget →

Expense tracker

Log what you spend: monthly totals by category and your tax-deductible total for the SARS year.

Open the tracker →

Cash in my pension?

Two-pot withdrawal when you change jobs: the tax, and what it takes off your retirement.

Price a withdrawal →

Tax

SARS income tax and PAYE on your salary, worked out line by line.

Check my PAYE →

Travel deduction

What a SARS logbook saves you on a travel allowance: cost scale against actual cost.

Work out my deduction →

Tax-free savings

Use your yearly TFSA allowance and see what it grows to by retirement.

Open TFSA →

Emergency fund

How many months your savings would carry you if the salary stopped.

Check my cushion →

Debt payoff

Snowball versus avalanche on your actual debts: which to clear first, and when you are free.

Plan my payoff →

Property & finance

Bond affordability

What you can borrow at prime, and what the repayment does to your budget.

Check my bond →

Transport

Car: cash, finance or lease

Cash, bank finance, a balloon or a lease on one graph: which costs least.

Compare the four ways →

Electric or hybrid car

The extra price against the fuel and servicing it saves: the year it pays for itself.

Compare my car →

Electricity, solar & water

Solar break-even

Your installer’s quote against the electricity it saves: the year solar pays for itself.

When does solar pay? →

Rainwater tank or borehole

Municipal water against a tank or a borehole, at published SA tariffs.

Compare my water →

Electricity tariffs

Eskom and municipal tariffs priced on the kWh you use each month.

Compare tariffs →

Compare what you pay

Bank account fees

Every bank’s published fees, priced on the transactions you actually make.

Price my bank fees →

Savings & fixed-deposit rates

Published interest rates on savings and fixed-deposit accounts, side by side.

Compare rates →

Personal loan costs

What a personal loan really costs per lender: rate, fees and total repaid.

Compare loans →

Tax-free savings accounts

TFSA products compared: cash, fixed deposit and shares, with their fees.

Compare TFSAs →

Fibre packages

Fibre and wireless packages by speed and monthly price.

Compare fibre →